Soldier Number 5 - Brothers In Arms

Updated: May 11

The "Brothers in Arms Memorial" is a new memorial in Flanders Fields, completed in 2021. The memorial is located within walking distance of Polygon Wood and is to be officially unveiled on 25th September 2022.

We Will Remember Them


The following poem is the original work of Irene Dalgety Timpone, from Atherton in Queensland, Australia. "My mother, Annie Trace Dalgety, was a first cousin of Jack and Jim Hunter. Her father, John Henry Trace, and Jack and Jim’s mother, Emily Trace, were siblings. Consequently, I heard the story of Jack and Jim in World War I from childhood, both from my mother and from my Aunt, Emily Louisa Trace who was our family historian. The story had special relevance to our family because Mum’s brothers, Ben and Percy, served in World War II.


I chose to write the poem in the Australian Bush Ballad style because that was the dominant verse style for original poetry in Australia following on the success of Henry Lawson and Banjo Paterson in the late 1800s. Another reason for my choice of the Bush Ballad genre was its suitability for the telling of a tale about two boys from the Australian bush who, along with thousands of others, made Australia proud during the dark days of World War I, and since."


Soldier Number Five


Who is the soldier lying there? He almost looks alive!

He’s known to God; but till we know, he’s Soldier Number Five.


Alas, no blue of Aussie skies could meet his sightless gaze.

The autumn chill of northern climes did not match Queensland days.

No warm and balmy breezes told of spring across the foam

or teased his mind with subtle hints of family and home.

No scent of bunya pine or eucalyptus tinged the air;

no loving brother’s hand was there to smooth his soft, brown hair.

Instead, a stranger plied great skill to raise him from the earth,

then find his name and trace him to his origins of birth…


In Flanders Fields, a backhoe gouged the soil, one autumn day.

Beneath a bridge, outside Westhoek, road works were under way.

The digger shuddered to a halt! The bucket had revealed

clear signs of Great War uniforms for many years concealed.

“Another one for Johan!” – words that echoed all around –

“Another one, or more, perhaps, still waiting to be found.”

An expert team soon gathered there with Johan Vandewalle.

Four days of effort then exposed five Aussie boys, in all.


For ninety years, they’d lain at rest beneath the Belgian sod,

revealed, at last, by human hands, perhaps the will of God.

Now, four were variations of the customary find:

some tattered clothes and shattered bones were all Time left behind.

But Number Five was different! His body seemed complete

for every strapping inch of him from head to booted feet.

His arms were neatly folded; hands were crossed upon his chest.

His body lay serenely posed for classic Christian rest.


A death mask shaped the features of his strong and handsome face.

The corpse, intact, defied the rules of earthly time and place.

The body had been wrapped so well, with tender, grieving care.

A loved one had a hand in this. The evidence was there.

The groundsheet was meticulously wrapped around, and tight,

with signal wire to bind it closed, ensure it held just right.

The team then used their well-honed skill to open back the sheath,

all sick at heart because they knew the horror underneath.


Forgive me, please,” said Johan, easing back the make-shift shroud,

just as a brilliant flash of sun pierced through a drifting cloud.

The sunlight caught the ravaged face, reflected in the eyes,

and Johan felt emotion that he could not recognize.

He’d seen a glint of colour in eye-sockets, deeply set,

a transcendental moment that he never would forget.

He sensed a poignant kinship with his Soldier Number Five,

a strange communication that he swore he’d keep alive.


Then Johan made a solemn vow to, one day, follow back

the footsteps of those Aussie boots; but, first, he had to track

five long-lost soldiers, knowing only when and where they died,

to give them the identities they’d been, too long, denied.

Australian media appeals brought forth a quick reply.

One name, already on short lists, had caught the public eye.

John Hunter, always known as Jack, was Soldier Number Five:

his brother, Jim, a soldier, too, had kept Jack’s tale alive.


From Hunter photo albums and from tales of local lore,

Johan soon pieced together Jim’s sad story of the war.

The boys signed up together, much against their father’s will.

They trained together, fought together, side by side, until

the morning of a battle that set Aussie pride on high,

the fiercest on the Western Front where thousands more would die.

Jim heard, above the battle-roar, “Your brother Jack just fell!”

He left his place and doubled back two miles of man-made Hell.


A world away from sun-drenched trees and fields they’d left unsown,

Jim found his wounded brother, spoke of happy times they’d known.

Jack strained to listen to the words, but uttered not a sound,

quite deaf to screams of dying men and horses all around.

Jim took his brother in his arms and stretched out by his side,

Spoke loving words of comfort and, caressed him till he died.

With words of sad farewell to Jack, one loving, long embrace,

Jim gazed one last, heart-broken time upon Jack’s well-loved face.


Upon the shell-shocked, wooded ridge, the nightmare battled on,

Jim had a duty to perform and then he must be gone.

Preparing Jack for burial, he took the greatest care,

then placed him in a make-shift grave, a rough cross showing where.

The battle over, Jim returned to find Jack’s resting place.

No chance of that, the canon-shells had left no single trace.

Jim soldiered on. We won the war. Australia brought him back.

Though life went on, a fine one too, he always longed for Jack.


New gravestones form a row of five in Butte’s War Cemetery,

More symbols of men’s wasted lives and war’s futility.

Five men were lost for ninety years in rough graves where they fell.

Three of those Aussies have been named, their stories ours to tell.

But two are unidentified! It is a dreadful shame

that soldiers sacrificing life should also lose their name.

Their histories lie secret in sad graves for ever more,

another senseless outcome of the “war to end all war”.


Who is the soldier lying there? He almost looks alive!

He’s known to God; but till we know, he’s Soldier Number Five.


3504 Private John Hunter 49th AIF

Killed in Action 26 September 1917


© Irene Dalgety Timpone, Atherton, Queensland, Australia


0 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All